Manolo Quezon is #TheExplainer Newsletter - Barons ascend when weak Monarchs rule
My column yesterday argued at its core, a weak presidency cultivated an image of strength enough to sap the vitality of national institutions including parties. Local parties filled the resulting power vacuum changing the political landscape.
This week's The Long View
Barons assembling | Inquirer Opinion — opinion.inquirer.net
By: Manuel L. Quezon III - @inquirerdotnet
Philippine Daily Inquirer / 04:07 AM November 24, 2021
Back in October, there was talk in diplomatic circles that provincial politicos have been consolidating among themselves and nominating one representative to deal with whoever becomes president as a single bloc, to have the most leverage for political survival. Because of the Supreme Court’s historic Mandanas Ruling in 2018, the internal revenue allotments of local governments are scheduled to increase by 55 percent. The present administration got the ball rolling on “devolution transition plans” which all sounds nice, but there are concerns over what the national government will choose to declare as devolved, as well as whether local governments are able, and not just willing, to absorb additional funds. What diplomats were talking about suggests a pragmatic recognition by local governments that they have to present a united front to the next administration.
It also suggests that the past six years of paradoxical “strongman rule” — paradoxical, because for all the bullying and bluster and ability to hog the limelight of the incumbent, President Duterte’s administration has been, in many ways, not strong, but rather, a weak one — and the resulting atrophy in our national institutions which all developed a bad case of Stockholm Syndrome with the President, means power has leached into unexpected places.
These places range from the police, who exercised more local power than at any time since martial law, to local political parties responding to the almost-permanent state of disruption in what passes for the ruling coalition (exceeded only by the starvation in resources being experienced by the opposition). This meant that over the past six years, two of the last old-style national parties, the Liberals and both wings of the PDP-Laban (Lakas-CMD, like Voldemort, was withered for a time but has regained some of its former plumpness), have withered away, while the national parties that exist as corporate subsidiaries, the Nacionalistas, National Unity, and Nationalist People’s Coalition, are no longer perceived to be mounting truly national, resource-rich, operations on the scale and scope of the past.
Five days ago, Hugpong ng Pagbabago, the regional party, announced that Davao City Mayor Sara Duterte was once again its chair after having resigned to join Lakas-CMD, which made her its chair. Having become that party’s official candidate, and officer, she apparently could resume membership in her regional party. Yesterday, local political party Bando Osmeña-Pundok Kauswagan or BOPK announced that it was endorsing Leni Robredo. The party’s mayoral bet, Margot Osmeña, cited as one reason Robredo agreeing to petition the Comelec to create special precincts for over a hundred thousand call center agents “who work in one area in Cebu City.”
If October to November was a shell game involving substitutions for final candidates, then it can be said that the real action is taking place in the regional and local parties. Cebu alone has the following clan-centered local parties: the previously-mentioned Bando Osmeña-Pundok Kauswagan; 1-CEBU of Gwendolyn Garcia and Kugi Uswag Sugbo of Alvin Garcia; Barug Alang sa Kauswagan ug Demokrasya of the Duranos; Partido Barug of Michael Rama; and the recently-revived Partido Panaghiusa (originally formed in the anti-Marcos days, an era which saw the monolithic national Kilusang Bagong Lipunan gobble up the old NP and LP, with newer, more regional-centric parties taking up the resistance; PDP-Laban’s own origins date to this era, the time of Panaghiusa in Cebu and the Mindanao Alliance).
Of the presidential candidates, three have their local parties: Asenso Manileño of Isko Moreno; People’s Champ Movement of Manny Pacquiao; Hugpong sa Tawong Lungsod of the Dutertes, while Daughterte herself is the on-again, off-again, chair of Hugpong ng Pagbabago which is a notch above these others, because it is a regional “aggrupation,” as we vividly like to call such things (there is, literally, an Aggrupation of Parties for Prosperity in Zamboanga).
It’s interesting to note that as local and regional leaders have learned to game the party list system, the affiliation of some national candidates includes attracting party list bigwigs, such as Lito Atienza of Buhay being Pacquiao’s running mate.
Email: mlquezon3@gmail.com; Twitter: @mlq3
Additional background
When the history of this admin's written, one will see how its chest-thumping disguised its inability to actually effect political change. Example: like all admins, it postponed barangay polls, but failed its ultimate objective, to appoint barangay OIC's.
Another element that will prove to have mattered politically was the President's own limited attention and support to candidates: he only ever truly cared for a few at a time, which ensured they'd be outnumbered in the end.
Related to today's column, it was in 2019 that I first suggested national parties were permanently in decline while local or regional ones were rising.
While in that year I suggested there was also a slower, but inexorable, unraveling of our being a nation with institutions and a people striving for Western-oriented modernity; we were backsliding instead into a premodern state of affairs.
In this column I proposed there were really two visions of political rule competing, the reformist and the business-as-usual, with the administration of today like that of 2001-2010, facing political and financial disaster if it should lose power.
It was also in this, and earlier columns, that I used the term "baron" to refer to local leaders to reflect their mindset and role.
Ambiguously Democratic: Parties, Coalitions, and Candidates in the 2022 Philippine Elections | Heinrich Böll Foundation | Southeast Asia Regional Office — th.boell.org Elections in the Philippines is a time of alliances, pundits, politicking within and across party lines. A range of candidates have put themselves forward for the upcoming 2022 elections, though their agendas and positions may still be too cloudy for voters to make a clear bet. Persistent problems around politics are present, although reform via the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) is slowly taking place. There’s still plenty of time ahead for unpredictability, by prospective candidates and the voting population.
The end of social mobility revisited
My latest podcast: In 2009 I first put forward a theory I've explored since: the implications of the rise of a "new" middle class and the inability of our political system to reform itself suggested a Marcos restoration wasn't possible but rather probable. The two columns are Permanently poor and The end of social mobility, both from February, 2009.
Manolo Quezon is #TheExplainer Podcast: Episode 17 The end of social mobility — anchor.fm This is an audio long read of a Long View column of mine, "The end of social mobility," published on February 26, 2009 in the Philippine Daily Inquirer. For the sake of context, I've included the first four paragraphs from a previous column, "Permanently poor," published on February 22, 2009. I ventured a thesis I have returned to time and again, since then: the implications of the rise of a "new" middle class, and the inability of our political system to reform itself. So it was in this piece, from 2009, that I suggested the restoration of the Marcoses was not just a possibility, but an increasing probability.
Thank you!
Your subscribing to this newsletter helps keep up my productivity and for those of you giving of yourselves to help through Patreon, it also makes a big difference to writing morale. As it’s been evolving this newsletter helps me flesh out my ideas, which then get distilled into my column, which then provides at launching pad for expanding those ideas, and so on.
Thank you to those who are contributing to Patreon and thus helping provide the resources required to keep producing this newsletter and podcast.
Consul: Abigail Salta
Praetors: Carlos v. Jugo, Ramon Rufino, Arbet Bernardo
Aediles: Steven Rood, Willi, Cleve Arguelles
Quaestors: Joseph Planta, Giancarlo Angulo, Annie Inojo,
Sam Chittick, Patrice P
Their support enables me to devote the time and effort for this newsletter and my podcast. Thank you!
Check out:
Become a patron of Manolo Quezon is #TheExplainer today: Get access to exclusive content and experiences on the world’s largest membership platform for artists and creators.